NYC has a quite low crime rate, but it needs a very low crime rate because commuting in a metal box underground with strangers can be nerve-wracking if even a few strangers are dangerous loons. For example, a psycho pushing a commuter off a platform in front of a subway train doesn’t happen very often, but each time it does, it reverberates in the minds of millions of commuters for months.

The good news is it wouldn’t take El Salvador–style mass arrests to make commuting in NYC less worrisome. Just about anybody who might someday push somebody off a subway platform has already earned his way onto lists of scary guys kept by NYC’s countless agencies.

Mostly, what’s lacking is the will and the institutions to lock up a few hundred deranged dudes, as I pointed out in a Taki’s column last May on how the same reforming instinct that led to a huge investment in massive lunatic asylums in peaceful rural surroundings in the mid-19th century led to the shutting down of these refuges in the later 20th century.

From the New York Times news section:

Kendra’s Law Was Meant to Prevent Violence. It Failed Hundreds of Times.

New York’s premier monitoring program for people with mental illness has broken down repeatedly, including in five cases involving subway shovings.

By Amy Julia Harris and Jan Ransom

Dec. 21, 2023

After John Skeene served prison time for beating his mother to death with a chair leg, after he attacked a man with a radiator cover and threatened to murder his therapist, New York State placed him in its gold-standard program for treating mentally ill people at risk of committing violence.

The program, which grew out of legislation known as Kendra’s Law and has been held up as a national model, was supposed to ensure that Mr. Skeene complied with a court-ordered treatment plan despite being homeless and living with schizoaffective disorder.

But by late 2018, there were signs that he was once again becoming unstable. He terrorized workers in his Queens transitional housing program, records show, banging on desks and kicking doors until they called 911. After subsequent outbursts, and while he was off his medications, the workers tried to send him for a hospital psychiatric evaluation, but he refused.

Under Kendra’s Law, his treatment team could have forced him to go anyway, but it apparently did not take that step, records show. Soon after, Mr. Skeene cornered a mental health worker in her office and punched her 30 times in the face, fracturing her eye socket and damaging her brain. She spent the next six months in the hospital, and, when she emerged, had to relearn how to walk. Mr. Skeene, then 59, went to prison.

For years, New York has used Kendra’s Law to force the seriously mentally ill people it has judged to be most at risk of committing acts of violence to receive psychiatric treatment, with the goal of protecting the patient and the public alike. Enacted in 1999, the law was designed to ensure that dangerous breakdowns never occurred again.

But a New York Times investigation has found that people under Kendra’s Law orders have been accused of committing more than 380 subway shovings, beatings, stabbings and other violent acts in the past five years alone. …

At least five people who were or had been under the court-ordered monitoring pushed people onto the subway tracks—the very act, carried out by a man with untreated schizophrenia, that led to the creation of Kendra’s Law in the first place.